Wisdom of the Few?
Wisdom of the Few? “Supertaggers” in Collaborative Tagging Systems
Jared Lorince, Sam Zorowitz, Jaimie Murdock, Peter M. Todd
A folksonomy is ostensibly an information structure built up by the “wisdom of the crowd”, but is the “crowd” really doing the work? Tagging is in fact a sharply skewed process in which a small minority of “supertagger” users generate an overwhelming majority of the annotations. Using data from three large-scale social tagging platforms, we explore (a) how to best quantify the imbalance in tagging behavior and formally define a supertagger, (b) how supertaggers differ from other users in their tagging patterns, and (c) if effects of motivation and expertise inform our understanding of what makes a supertagger. Our results indicate that such prolific users not only tag more than their counterparts, but in quantifiably different ways. These findings suggest that we should question the extent to which folkosonomies achieve crowdsourced classification via the “wisdom of the crowd”, especially for broad folksonomies like Last.fm as opposed to narrow folksonomies like Flickr.
Preprint of article in review available atÂ arXiv:1502.02777 [cs.SI]